The Megyn Kelly Show: Nolan Wells Case, Misinformation, and Media Spin

**Megyn Kelly** (0:01)
We need to talk about the Nolan Wells case, because this has become a national story and the facts are getting lost in the outrage. 18-year-old Mississippi College freshman disappeared after a Fourth of July boat trip to Horn Island. He was with childhood friends, and his body was later found.
Now his family has brought in Benjamin Crump and Al Sharpton.

**MK True Crime** (0:23)
And that's where this got complicated, right? Because once Crump and Sharpton got involved, this became a racial storyline before we even knew what happened. The family has legitimate questions about deleted phone data, missing photos, confusing accounts from that day.
But authorities have said they don't suspect foul play.

**Megyn Kelly** (0:42)
Exactly. The official autopsy is still pending. Colin Kaepernick paid for an independent preliminary autopsy, and Crump said the cause of death was undetermined pending further investigation.
So we don't have answers yet, but we're already getting a narrative.

**MK True Crime** (0:59)
What about that audio clip that was going around? The one people said was Nolan saying, give me my freaking phone.

**Megyn Kelly** (1:05)
That's a perfect example of the misinformation. Turns out that was later identified as Tristan Shepard's voice, not Nolan's. And remember that pool party photo Crump posted on Instagram, suggesting something suspicious happened that day?
Metadata showed it was from a week earlier.

**MK True Crime** (1:24)
So we're being fed fragments, not conclusions.
Building on that point, there's still no evidence the friends harmed him. This could come down to drowning, rip currents, bad timing. Caitlin Becker even said the group's version may be incomplete, but pointing fingers without hard evidence isn't prudent.

**Megyn Kelly** (1:44)
And then there's Sharpton's rhetoric. He brought up Kane and Abel, turned the press conference into something bigger than Nolan himself.
There was this phrase that really captured the problem. We can't say it was racist, but we cannot say it was not racist. That's not how evidence works.

**MK True Crime** (2:03)
Right.
Let's shift to the other cases covered in this episode. What's happening with Carmelo Anthony's appeal?

**Megyn Kelly** (2:10)
Prosecutors say the defense's claim about an off-the-record deal over character evidence is contradicted by the trial transcript. The panel thinks the argument looks weak because pellet courts don't usually care about informal handshake agreements.

**MK True Crime** (2:25)
And Sunny Hostin's son, Gabriel, got cited for trespassing near railway tracks in New Rochelle. That probably would have been handled quietly, but it became public after Hostin confronted police and invoked her son's education and credentials.

**Megyn Kelly** (2:39)
Then there's the Timothy Busfield case. His grand jury testimony included the line, I don't remember ever kissing either one of those boys.
The panel noted the parents' background complicates things, and Kelly said she'd likely dismiss it as a prosecutor.

**MK True Crime** (2:56)
The through line here is clear, isn't it? Wait for evidence, not outrage. Whether it's Nolan Wells, Carmelo Anthony, or any of these cases, the rush to judgment before facts are established creates more problems than it solves.
That's the message.

**Megyn Kelly** (3:15)
Let the investigations finish. Let the evidence speak.