Luigi Mangione’s High-Risk Legal Strategy

**SPEAKER_1** (0:00)
This podcast is supported by the Conservation Fund. For over 40 years, the Conservation Fund has raced to protect at-risk land before it's lost. The forests, farmland, open spaces and places that wildlife call home. They believe conservation shouldn't be a choice between protecting nature and supporting people.
It should advance both in harmony. With over 9 million acres protected across all 50 states, the Conservation Fund secures the irreplaceable lands people love. Learn more at conservationfund.org.

**Zolan Kano-Youngs** (0:34)
From The New York Times, I'm Zolan Kano-Youngs, filling in as host. This is The Daily.
In the two years since a masked man shot and killed a health care executive, the national spotlight has turned to one primary suspect, Luigi Mangione.

**SPEAKER_3** (0:56)
Newly released video of the moment, prosecutors say Luigi Mangione gunned down UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Todd.

**SPEAKER_4** (1:02)
In that notebook, though, apparently, there's multiple notes, writings from Mangione, as well as other notes.

**SPEAKER_5** (1:08)
Mounting evidence collected by investigators continue to link 26-year-old Luigi Mangione to the murder.

**Zolan Kano-Youngs** (1:14)
The overwhelming evidence has pointed to his guilt. And the question on most minds has been, what might the defense of one of the most famous murder suspects in America look like?

**SPEAKER_6** (1:24)
A lot of anticipation and a line of people outside federal court in New York City today.

**Zolan Kano-Youngs** (1:29)
On Friday, in a single hearing, we got our first glimpse at an answer, one that appears to include a full-throated embrace of his guilt. Today, my colleagues Benjamin Weiser and Hurubie Meko on the risky defense strategy of Luigi Mangione and why an admission of guilt might be his best bet.
It's Monday, August 17th.
So Hurubie and Ben, you two have been following the prosecution of Luigi Mangione for almost two years. This has been happening on a number of different fronts. I think it's overwhelming for many people. Mangione faces multiple charges for multiple different crimes in both state and federal court, all centered around one act, the assassination of Brian Thompson, the United Healthcare CEO. And on Friday, we got our first glimpse of how these different threads might play out in court. Ben, how would you characterize what we saw?

**Benjamin Weiser** (2:37)
All of the pieces of this brazen assassination from back in December 2024, the killing on a Manhattan sidewalk that really riveted the nation, fell into place in front of our eyes. And we heard from Mangione for the very first time in public. When he pled guilty, he entered a guilty plea before a judge and explained what he had done that made him believe he was guilty.

**Zolan Kano-Youngs** (3:05)
A guilty plea. Hurubie, when I hear that, I kind of wonder, okay, is this a wrap? Is it over?
Is that the case?

**Hurubie Meko** (3:13)
Not quite. So he's entered a guilty plea in the federal case, but he still has a state case that is still looming. And there could be months of litigation on that front. So the case is far from over.

**Zolan Kano-Youngs** (3:24)
Far from over. Okay, let's get into this. Let's talk through the different elements of the state case, the federal case, all of these cases against Luigi Mangione. How has his legal defense evolved from the moment of his arrest?

**Hurubie Meko** (3:41)
Sure, so from his arrest in Altoona, Pennsylvania, the Manhattan District Attorney's Office almost immediately charged him with 11 counts, including terrorism and second-degree murder. And as he was being extradited to New York, and as he landed in New York City, the Manhattan federal prosecutors announced that they too would be charging him.

**Benjamin Weiser** (4:02)
Yeah, the United States Justice Department brought four counts, notably one was use of a firearm to commit murder, which carries a maximum potential sentence of death if the government decides to seek it. There were also two counts of interstate stalking, in a sense, stalking him over state lines, stalking the victim, resulting in the death of Thompson, and that carried a maximum sentence of life. There was an additional firearm charge, but those were the four counts initially brought by the federal government.
And in announcing those charges, the United States Attorney at the time, this was the Biden administration, said explicitly that they expected the Manhattan DA's office to try Mangione first, and that the United States Attorney's office would follow.

**Zolan Kano-Youngs** (4:52)
So the feds are deferring to the state authorities in some way. They're saying you're going to be kind of the lead on this and take the first crack at it.

**Benjamin Weiser** (5:01)
That's right. But several months after Trump was elected and took office, the Attorney General at the time, Pam Bondi, announced that the administration was going to seek the death penalty.