163 Kids Found in FL, Lindsay Clancy Verdict, Montana Family Annihilator & Girl Hires BF to Kill Mom artwork

163 Kids Found in FL, Lindsay Clancy Verdict, Montana Family Annihilator & Girl Hires BF to Kill Mom

Serialously with Annie Elise

September 3, 2026

This week on Headline Highlights: Carson Peters-Berger, who was 14 when he murdered his 10-year-old cousin Lily Peters, pleaded guilty to first-degree intentional homicide in a plea deal. Florida’s Operation Statewide Shield recovered 163 missing children in five days across the U.S. and abroad.
Speakers: Annie Elise, Amy

Topics: True Crime, News, Daily News

**Annie Elise** (0:02)
Hey, true crime besties, welcome back to an all new episode of Serialously.
Hello, hello, hello, welcome back to an all new episode of Serialously. With me, your true crime bestie and your host, Annie Elise, happy Thursday. As you know, Thursdays are Headline Highlights days where we're going through everything that is happening in true crime this week. A deep dive did come out on Monday. It was all about the Philly House of Horrors, Eugene Horsch, which talk about like the ultimate jump scare if you see his face and his dad's face. But I know so many of you have been asking for coverage on that. People suspect that he may be the United States worst serial killer in over 50 years. So, you know, doing what we do over here had to like dig through newspaper clippings, archival, and like get the backstory on not only Eugene, but also his disgusting ass dad. And so I released that deep dive for you on Monday. Go take a listen. You probably, for all my audio listeners, will also want to check out the YouTube video version though, because you've got to see these photos. It is like jump scare mania.
But that was the deep dive Monday. Today it's Headline Highlights, as I said, lots to go over. We have Lindsay Clancy verdict, the deadlocked jury on Tuesday, so much to discuss. We unfortunately somehow have a new family annihilator case out of Billings, Montana.
You have also been asking that I dig into the 163 kids that were found in Florida. We're digging into that. I actually tasked that on my expert guest host, ultimate frisbee champion, Amy Colette.

**Amy** (2:02)
Hello. Good morning.

**Annie Elise** (2:04)
Now, if you don't understand that reference, it's because you need to listen to last week's episode.

**Amy** (2:09)
For the record, I don't play frisbee.

**Annie Elise** (2:12)
You should.

**Amy** (2:13)
Annie wants to.

**Annie Elise** (2:14)
Apparently, it's a good exercise thing. I actually was going to tell you, we haven't talked about this yet. I don't know if you saw the comments on YouTube from last week's episode. A lot of people were surprised that we are actually sisters.

**Amy** (2:26)
No, I know.

**Annie Elise** (2:27)
So maybe it's a lot of new listeners who are understanding.

**Amy** (2:29)
I think it is.

**Annie Elise** (2:29)
Yes, guys, we are sisters. She's the older one.

**Amy** (2:33)
Barely.

**Annie Elise** (2:34)
Barely three years.

**Amy** (2:36)
Barely. And I remember for a long time people thought we were twins, obviously not with our hair right now, but how did they not even know we're sisters?

**Annie Elise** (2:44)
No, you guys sound alike. Are you sisters? And people were schooling them in the comments. Of course they're sisters, but yes, we are sisters and biologically sisters, not just sisters.

**Amy** (2:57)
Not just best friends.

**Annie Elise** (2:59)
Yeah. So I have tasked you today, or not today, but before, but you're going to cover that story because I just need a mental break for a minute.

**Amy** (3:07)
Yeah.

**Annie Elise** (3:07)
And I know it's wild, but-

**Amy** (3:09)
Yes. I gotcha.

**Annie Elise** (3:10)
Lots to get into. We also both have our foot up on the table right now, and we're both wearing the exact same shoes. What's happening?

**Amy** (3:17)
So that happened last week, and that was before I knew we were filming in the new set and you were going to see my feet. But then I was like, these are the perfect shoes because today I actually had open toed shoes and I felt like we don't need a foot finder. This isn't only foot finder.

**Annie Elise** (3:31)
Put your feet away.

**Amy** (3:32)
But we should be sponsored by Luso.

**Annie Elise** (3:34)
Luso, where's our boy Chris Noyes?

**Amy** (3:36)
Yeah, exactly. Sponsor us. Clip this.

**Annie Elise** (3:38)
Sponsor us. No, it's my brother's best friend's company. I told you guys about them before. They basically, weren't they modeled after-

**Amy** (3:45)
Oh, there you go.

**Annie Elise** (3:45)
There's a toes. Weren't they modeled after the Four Seasons Slipper?

**Amy** (3:49)
Yes.

**Annie Elise** (3:50)
And so, they're like this waffle. Look at me doing a sponsored ad and it's not even sponsored. Go ahead, zoom in. No, they're like this waffle material. They're slip-on shoes and they are so padded and comfy. I have them in like every color.

**Amy** (4:03)
And they're the best to fly in because my feet swell up. So.

**Annie Elise** (4:06)
Okay. I didn't need to go that far.
There was something else.

**Amy** (4:09)
Oh, yeah.

**Annie Elise** (4:10)
So back onto the sister comment. I told you before we started recording that I have a social media reel I want to film with you.

52 more minutes of transcript below

Thousands of transcripts fetched by people building searchable podcast archives

Feed this to your agent

Try it now — copy, paste, done:

curl -H "x-api-key: pt_demo" \
  https://spoken.md/transcripts/1000651996090

Works with Claude, ChatGPT, Cursor, and any agent that makes HTTP calls.

From $0.10 per transcript. No subscription. Credits never expire. Prices exclude VAT, added at checkout for EU customers. Not what you expected? Email us within 14 days with 20 or fewer credits used and we refund the pack in full.

Using your own key:

curl -H "x-api-key: YOUR_KEY" \
  https://spoken.md/transcripts/YOUR_EPISODE_ID