Why the Cultural Monoculture Is Officially Over | Ruby Thelot
MTS
November 4, 2026
Ruby Justice Thelot analyzes how algorithmic curation and platform economics have fractured cultural monoculture, flattening mainstream pop while accelerating niche subcultures.
Ruby Justice Thelot
What we lose in monoculture, we gain in personal curiosity, in personal cultural exploration. What we lose in cultural common ground, in this shared common cultural world, like thinking about knowing all the same celebrities, knowing all the same musicians, we gain in creating more cultural diversity. And so we now have what I consider to be a rich, blossoming cultural ecosystem. It is not found on the high streets, it is found on the margins.
Hi, and welcome to this second episode of Media Studies. This show, as you now know, is about media, culture, and technology. We spend time observing the trends of the day and trying to support or infirm them by providing sort of data-driven approach to understanding our culture. As I said yesterday, we are in a world of great cultural confusion, and Media Studies seeks to be a refuge from the deluge of trends and whatnot. We ask, is this real or is this not? And hopefully, provide proof or examples to support or deny or decline, or make it clear that something might be overblown or overrepresented on social media.
Our first signal for today, right? We start with these signals every time. Things that we're seeing in culture, articles, things that are picking up on social media. Concerns the formerly number one song in America. Because of my work, I get to travel quite a bit. I recently was in San Francisco, in London. I've done this specific lecture I'm going to be referring to. Also in Jersey and here in New York. It's a lecture called, Why are there no new aesthetics? The No New Aesthetics Lecture is often very well attended by students, artists, designers, content strategists, people who in many ways are at the forefront of making culture. They work at Nike, at very cool brand and agency studios, right?
And I started asking a simple question at the beginning of the lecture. The lecture's question, of course, that the central thesis of the lecture is why are there no new aesthetics? Why are we feeling somewhat stuck in a culture that feels arrested, that feels stagnant? And so, to my beloved members of the Intelligencia, I ask a very simple question, which is what is, and think about this summer, right? What is the number one song in America? I'll give you a little bit of time to think about that. Maybe you know the answer, maybe you don't. And maybe when I reveal the name of the song, you'll say, oh boy, I've never heard that song in my life. At this point, this song has been, I think, the number one on Billboard for 20 weeks, the longest run for a singer-songwriter, beating, I believe, Whitney Houston and Mariah Carey. She was recently dethroned by Taylor Swift, the other great leader of our pop culture. This song is none other than Choosing Texas by Ella Langley. Now, some of you may or may not know this song. If you spend a lot of time in Target, perhaps you do. And if you don't, I say this with absolute love, it is important for the people watching the show to be au fait, to be made aware of what actually is happening in culture, right? We can listen to whatever the new Avalanche's record or whatever cool things are happening here in New York or elsewhere in the world, but I think it's very important for us to be tapped into what is actually going on in contemporary American in this context, popular culture. And so this idea that choosing Texas could be the largest song in the world I think was shocking for some because they had not been exposed to it. And I think this signal is actually globbed on with a few other things. There's an article in the Times by Lauren Leake, today or yesterday, where Lauren is a data scientist who took a look at all the different stores on the high streets in London, took a look at the lyric composition of the top songs, and found which I could only describe as a landing in a lot of popular culture. This is something she of course laments. My dear friend Kyle Sheikha of course has written a book about this, Filtered World.
In many ways, my other dear friend W. David Marks also has a great book about this called Blank Space. A lot of these texts study contemporary culture and try to identify why it feels so stagnant. Kyle's answer of course is that it's the algorithm's fault, right? Our music, our images, our style are filtered through these algorithms, and they have a downstream impact on what people are wearing, doing, listening to.
For Marks, W. David that is of course, not Carl, the history of contemporary pop culture is one where commercialization has an impact and forecloses the possibility for novelty in contemporary culture. For Lauren, as she studies the data, taking a look at London, take a look at these popular songs, she seems to be identifying that algorithms also are the thing that pushes things toward a sense of the average. So we'll be spending more time with that in our last deep dive today.
Read the other 37 minutes of this episode here.
$15 gets you this episode and 99 more. Credits never expire. After checkout, one link brings you back here to read it.
Not what you expected? Full refund within 14 days.
Thousands of transcripts fetched by people building searchable podcast archives
Fetch transcripts with code
The same credits work from a script or an AI agent. The demo key returns a sample episode in full, no card needed:
curl -H "x-api-key: pt_demo" \
https://spoken.md/transcripts/1000651996090Markdown with the speakers named, for your notes, your knowledge base, or anything that makes HTTP calls.
From $0.10 per transcript. No subscription. Credits never expire. Prices exclude VAT, added at checkout for EU customers. Not what you expected? Email us within 14 days with 20 or fewer credits used and we refund the pack in full.
Using your own key:
curl -H "x-api-key: YOUR_KEY" \
https://spoken.md/transcripts/1000799840028