What Happened To Jesse Butler's Eleven Convictions

**Tony Brueski** (0:01)
This is Hidden Killers With Tony Brueski.

**Tony Brueski** (0:11)
Every time this guy's picture shows up on the graphic behind me, I throw up in my mouth a little bit. Jesse Butler out of Stillwater, Oklahoma. We're still talking about him because, well, even though his case essentially has now expired and the judge has basically dismissed the charges under the Youthful Offender Act of Oklahoma, even though he did horrible, horrible things to two young girls that they will never fully recover from. Why do we do this? Why do we keep talking about this? Why do we have a gazillion videos about this monstrous piece of genetic, rejected genetic goo named Jesse Butler, in my opinion? Because someday, there's going to be somebody out there who's bamboozled by him that does a Google search on Jesse Butler. I'm sure he's probably going to have to use a different name. But it will come out. Somebody will connect some dots like, oh, that guy named Steve over there? That's Jesse Butler. What do you mean? Google him. Just do a quick Google. Just YouTube him. And then, hi, hi, if you're just joining us, if you're new to the party and you were living a life of relative peace and comfort and non-chaos and you're somehow involved with this guy, well, you got a little bit of homework to do, but we're going to do it for you. We're going to give you all you need to know about Jesse Butler so you can make an informed decision to run for your freaking life or call the police, depending on what he's done to you so far.
Because I don't believe this man is going to live a life of freedom. People that are capable of doing these sort of things, they don't tend to stop. They don't tend to change. It tends to be baked in, especially when you have a family like his that seems to mesh themselves around the horrific criminal behavior. Go, it's okay. No, no, no. That girl, she shouldn't have told on you, Jesse. It's not your fault. No, you were just strangling her nearly to death while you were violating her horribly. You're a good little boy. You're a good little boy. You play baseball. You're a good boy. Hey, hey, hey, hey.
Yeah, I'm sorry to break it to you if you are meeting this man, but he seemed so nice. All American baseball player originally from Stillwater, Oklahoma, or whatever line of bullshit he's going to have to use for his fake alibi of his life going forward.
Here's what you're getting. Okay. Again, this is why we do it. To inform, to help educate, to protect anybody who has an ounce of sense to do a Google on the people that they that they come across in their life. On his 19th birthday, his record disappears like it never happened. A mother said that out loud in a Payne County courtroom in December of 25 She was describing the deal her family had just watched a judge approved. Jesse Mack Butler.
Could you get more Oklahoma of a name? Turn 19 on August 4th of 2026, a judge in Stillwater dismissed his criminal case on August 3rd of one day early. The Office of Juvenile Affairs had certified that he finished every requirement with no violations. Butler had faced up to 78 years. He served 150 hours of community service and paid about $3,300. He never spent a night in a cell. His attorney says the next step is asking the judge to seal the record. The state of Oklahoma cannot touch him again. The people still trying to make him answer are a girl's parents and an insurance company. One of the girls needed surgery on her throat. That's how much this wasn't just two teens went too far and one of the parents wanted to press charges. No, this ain't that.
This is a guy who, the odds are high, statistically speaking, that he could very easily harm or kill someone, considering he's so into strangling teenage girls.
Well, he's allegedly assaying them.
She was 16 Fillings in her, filings, rather, in her family's civil case, say Butler, choked her in a Walmart parking lot in 2024 until she nearly died. And then a doctor told her afterwards how close it had been. She had dated him. So had the other girl who came forward. Both were 16 Both were students at Stillwater High School. Stillwater Police opened the investigation in September of 24 Prosecutors charged Butler as an adult the following March with 11 felony counts, including two counts of domestic assault and battery by strangulation and one kind of violating a protective order. He was 16 and 17 when the incidents described and the charges took place. He was never taken into custody, not for one night at any point in the case. The attorneys asked the court to treat him as a juvenile. And it was actually initially denied on July 24th, 25th. Special Judge Susan Worthington then stepped in.