The search for dark matter has been blown wide open

**Matt Honan** (0:00)
Welcome to MIT Technology Review Narrated. My name is Matt Honan. I'm our Editor-in-Chief.
Every week, we'll bring you a fascinating, new, in-depth story from the leading edge of science and technology, covering topics like AI, biotech, climate, energy, robotics, and more. Here's this week's story. I hope you enjoy it.

**SPEAKER_2** (0:22)
Narrated by NOAA. Listen to more of the best articles from the world's biggest publishers on the NOAA app, or at newsoveraudio.com.

**Sam Scholl** (0:34)
Dan Garisto writes, The search for dark matter has been blown wide open.
Underneath an aponine massif, below the Jinping Mountains of Sichuan, and at the bottom of a South Dakota mine, there is a cosmic hunt afoot. Isolated deep beneath these rocky shields, massive detectors filled with liquid xenon aim to make the first direct detections of dark matter, the long-sought invisible substance whose gravity has sculpted our universe. The hope is that someday, a bit of dark matter called a weakly interacting massive particle, a WIMP for short, will collide with a xenon atom, creating a burst of light and electric charge. After running for years, these experiments have recently begun seeing infrequent blips from a particle that glides ethereally through ordinary matter, until it crashes into the detectors. Unfortunately, the new signal is not produced by dark matter. Instead, the detectors are picking up on something similarly insubstantial, but much more mundane. Neutrinos, the featherweight subatomic particles that the sun and other stars produce in massive quantities. Physicists have known for decades that this neutrino background was there. They were just hoping to discover WIMP dark matter first. Now, the chance is looking slim. Some of today's WIMP detectors are simply so large and sensitive, that they are entering the so-called neutrino fog, in which the ordinary particles are likely to drown out any signal from the main target. There is no shielding these detectors from neutrinos which easily slip through the earth itself. That means the next experiment to use this long-standing approach for seeking WIMP dark matter may be the last.
Hitting the neutrino fog does not, however, mean an end to the search for dark matter. Researchers just have to shift the focus of their hunt. We haven't seen WIMP dark matter, says Katherine Zurich, a theoretical particle physicist at the California Institute of Technology. Nor, she says, have scientists found new particles in the Large Hadron Collider, or LHC, the powerful proton-smashing facility that straddles the border between France and Switzerland. And so, people naturally broaden their scope, Zurich says. As they do, there are plenty more candidates waiting in the wings.
In other words, the hunt is transforming from a narrow probe into a kind of free-for-all. It's a big shift. Today, particle physicists are less sure about dark matter's identity than when they began looking for it. They'll freely admit that they cannot presume the basics. For example, if the stuff that makes up dark matter is heavier than the Earth, or lighter than a radio wave, or if dark matter is one kind of particle or a dozen. The uncertainty can be frustrating, even humbling. The potential range where the candidates could be is so enormous that the odds of any one small experiment finding it are very, very small, says Hugh Lippincott, a dark matter experimentalist at the University of California, Santa Barbara. But physicists' failure to find dark matter where they thought it was, has also led to a cornucopia of proposals for new ways to search. Quantum sensors, liquid helium-based detectors, searches in Jupiter's atmosphere and more. Now there's a great deal of excitement, and finally there's technology there, says Gray Ripka, a University of Washington physicist who co-leads an experiment looking for axions. An ultra-lightweight dark matter candidate.
Still, with so many places to look, where does it make sense for physicists to begin again? For starters, the birth of the universe. Dark matter has been with us since the beginning, and there's much to learn from those early eons. Maps of the cosmic microwave background, the first light from the universe's early years, are full of fluctuations caused by the clumpiness of underlying matter. Reading these cosmic dregs, researchers can tell that only 17% of the matter in the universe is made of ordinary particles like protons and neutrons. The remaining 83% is dark matter, which has little to no interaction with light or ordinary matter other than through gravity.
We can tell quite a bit about dark matter from those gravitational effects. We know that the Milky Way contains a halo of the stuff. Our own solar system orbits the galactic center far too quickly to be bound by the tug of ordinary matter alone. Without dark matter's gravitational tether, we would be flung off into intergalactic space. We can also see how the heft of a galaxy's dark matter bends the path of light as it makes its way to Earth's telescopes. And on the grandest scale, we can see how superclusters of galaxies are distributed in space, like dewdrops on a spider web. No cosmological theory without dark matter can explain all these phenomena.