Recruiters judging appearance and behavior, Softball with Margo, Tough Coaches
Everything Fastpitch - The Podcast
November 18, 2026
Welcome to Everything Fastpitch episode 447. In “Did You Know,” they note the NAIA is adopting the five-for-five eligibility model, discussing consistency across divisions, roster and recruiting impacts, fewer openings for incoming classes, and potential academic benefits of a fifth year.
Margo
Everything Fastpitch brings another great episode. Here's a brief clip. Technology is an amazing thing, you should use it as a coach. Have them film, you can FaceTime them, you can Zoom call them, see them swing, like they don't need to be physically in front of you for you to make an impact on their game. What they need is a plan.
Tory Acheson
Welcome to this week's edition of Everything Fastpitch by Fastpitch Prep. Coach Don and I are working on episode number 447 today. We have a really fun show lined up for you, very interesting Did You Know, City of the Week, Equipment Tip of the Week, and a really interesting listener question. In our lead-off and cleanup segments this week, we have an interview with Coach Margo from Softball with Margo. I'm sure many of you have seen her stuff on social media and we had a great conversation. And then our coaching tip of the week, we're going to talk about a concept that keeps coming up with listeners. And the basic premise is that it's okay to be a tough coach, but are you a good tough coach or a bad tough coach? We're going to talk about some ways to recognize things that might tell you what side of that coin you're falling on. So before we get into that, let's talk about patreon.com/everythingfastpitch.
Again, thank you very much to all of our patrons. Don and I really do appreciate the support. We would love to see some more people come on board. Again, got a great group of people that have been supporting us for a long time, but it's about time for us to add another couple of people to the team. If you see value in what you're doing, want to support the podcast, please go to patreon.com/everythingfastpitch, and it's all going to be explained to you there. Our warm up segment, Don, starting off with Did You Know, NAIA announced recently that they are also going to be switching to the five-for-five eligibility model, as now I believe across all levels of the four-year schools. Technically, I guess we'd have to start saying that they're five-year schools at the current model that we're in right now. It looks like everybody's allowing their players to play for five years.
NAIA was the last to join the wave, and it's a very interesting thing, and it's a really unusual time right now, I think, for everybody involved, and for the college coaches trying to manage the extra year of eligibility that many of their players now have, or people that are trying to get recruited, trying to figure out what it means for them now that there's less spots available. So, Don, what are your thoughts about the five-for-five and the NAIA?
Don McKinlay
Well, that's a two-sided look at that one, Tory, because I think that it's going to make it a lot easier for everybody if it's just consistent across the board.
If you're transferring from one affiliation to another and it's all the same, then I think that makes it a little bit easier between the years for us to conceptualize everything. But as you said, every time we look at this stuff, every time we do it, it's bumping one age group, it's bumping the spots available for one upcoming class. And it's just creating a little bit of havoc for those that are excited about getting a chance and an opportunity to come play in college. On that note, I feel disappointed for the kids that are coming up, but we always talk about things changing around us. And this is another one that's happening kind of as we watch. And it does give more opportunity for funding for kids that maybe either want to further their academic interests even after they graduate with that fifth year, get them started on a master's or a second degree. And we can turn it into a good thing, but it does certainly make it tougher for that next class of kids that are coming in and just fewer opportunities for a season and then we're back to normal with as we were. So it's a little bit challenging, but I think it's eventually going to be a good thing.
Tory Acheson
Well, eventually this will all cycle out and it won't feel like it's different. It's just really different now because schools have just been presented, colleges have been presented with a whole different opportunity. And I did see something on the last thing we'll talk about with this today, because we haven't talked about the five for five thing a little bit already, but that in division one, which obviously is not NAIA, which we're talking about today. But I saw a post that listed a really high number of schools, division one schools that have signed and have basically committed zero to almost zero high school kids. And then there's other programs, like a whole other list, that have committed to eight, nine, ten, twelve, fourteen high school kids. And so I think what's happening is that for the schools that are maybe less likely to get the transfers, maybe it is opening the door for them to get some more high school kids, and maybe even some better high school kids. But I hate the idea of a coach having to recruit somebody thinking about, I'm just a stepping stone for them to get to another school somewhere down the road. So Did You Know? NAIA has jumped on the five for five train. It looks like now we'll have to start saying five year schools instead of four.
Read the other 62 minutes of this episode here.
$15 gets you this episode and 99 more. Credits never expire. After checkout, one link brings you back here to read it.
Not what you expected? Full refund within 14 days.
Thousands of transcripts fetched by people building searchable podcast archives
Fetch transcripts with code
The same credits work from a script or an AI agent. The demo key returns a sample episode in full, no card needed:
curl -H "x-api-key: pt_demo" \
https://spoken.md/transcripts/1000651996090Markdown with the speakers named, for your notes, your knowledge base, or anything that makes HTTP calls.
From $0.10 per transcript. No subscription. Credits never expire. Prices exclude VAT, added at checkout for EU customers. Not what you expected? Email us within 14 days with 20 or fewer credits used and we refund the pack in full.
Using your own key:
curl -H "x-api-key: YOUR_KEY" \
https://spoken.md/transcripts/1000802787397