Nations Pod: Scotland’s All Blacks problem artwork

Nations Pod: Scotland’s All Blacks problem

Rugby Union Weekly

November 10, 2026

Why can’t Scotland beat the All Blacks? Chris, GRO and Tom pick through a second-half collapse at Murrayfield and ask whether the opening weekend of the Nations Championship needed an upset. What did England’s win over Australia tell us about Steve Borthwick’s side?

0:00

SPEAKER_1

5 Live's Rugby Union Weekly.

0:03

Chris

Rugby Union Weekly Nations Pod time. Weekend one of the Nations Championship done. Weekend two, hurtling interview.

Loads to talk about, loads to look forward to. GRO is here, Tom is here. Evening.

0:17

Tom

Hello, hello.

0:19

GRO

Yeah, how are we?

0:20

Chris

Yeah, we're good, I think. Mark's at a 10 for the opening weekend.

0:24

Tom

Quickly, top of the head.

0:25

GRO

Six, six, six.

0:26

Chris

Six, five.

0:26

Tom

I would say six, six, six, six, six and a half.

0:32

Chris

Six and a half.

0:34

Tom

Oh, you did the six, seven thing. That's very how young and trendy you are. Six, seven, gone. Have the young ones moved on to something else?

0:41

SPEAKER_1

Seven, eight, nine.

0:42

Chris

Yeah, my four-year-old has taken to doing that. I think it's trickled down the ages.

So, six and a half and sixes. Is that just the lack of jeopardy in some of the games that we touched upon on our pod the other day, the one with Ashley and Grace?

1:00

Tom

Lack of a big upset, really, I think. I think we needed something.

1:05

Chris

Are we getting many, though, in Test Rugby in general?

1:08

Tom

No, we're not.

1:09

Chris

I was thinking about this. I know in the Six Nations, when a few of England's games, because of the form they were coming into the championship, I think they would have bucked the form guy. But on the whole, when I look at all of those Nations Championship games in the summer and the ones on the weekend, have all of them been won by the favorites, do you think?

1:28

Tom

I'm trying to think back. I think some of the underdogs put up a bit of a fight along the way.

But yeah, I think they're all won by the favorites and probably in the end fairly comprehensively by the favorites.

1:44

GRO

Yeah, so I think this is the beauty and the issue now with the Nation Championship is we're entering a new era where this is being judged as a championship, as a competition, as opposed to a series of individual matches. So now I was thinking about this after the weekend, thinking, the Nation Championship not quite living up to the Six Nations. Well, that's a tough ask though, isn't it? And I think, going back to my idea of the framework of, you know, we've got, I always bang on about the fact that there's the tier one nations, tier two, I've always said there's like, there's three levels in this championship. In the top 12, there are three levels. France, New Zealand, South Africa, Ireland just hanging on maybe at that level.

Then there's the middle block, England right at the top with Scotland and Argentina.

And then there's the lower block. And you're only really getting tight contests when they're in the same block facing each other, or you've got those second teams just pushing up against Ireland, et cetera. So that's the concern we have, but that's the reality of the game and that's the reality of sport as it is. You start this brand new competition, you have 12 teams, there will be mismatches. And it's an inevitability.

3:07

Chris

It would be nice, wouldn't it, Tom, to see some movement. You know, I know that there are bigger fish to fry come next year with the World Cup, but in terms of this month, will we see some movement by the end? Someone move out of that top tier? Because as GRO says, yeah, it is quite clear the big fish in New Zealand showed why they're a big fish on the weekend. England showed where they're trying to be a big fish with their performance, but still have got a fair bit to prove. Do you think we will see someone make a run, make a dart?

3:37

Tom

See, I think it's a question whether Ireland are in that top tier that GRO talks about, or whether they have dropped down to the next tier. And we'll only know that when they place at Africa. I don't think we found out anything new on Friday night when they put Argentina away. So that's, I think Ireland have a chance maybe to make a move, but I still think that Africa are going to beat them. I don't really see anybody else making a move. Scotland had their chance to make a move at the weekend. They didn't take it.

England will have a chance to make a move. I doubt that they're going to take it, to be honest. So I think it's going to be as we were come the end of this championship.

Read the other 56 minutes of this episode here.

$15 gets you this episode and 99 more. Credits never expire. After checkout, one link brings you back here to read it.

Not what you expected? Full refund within 14 days.

Thousands of transcripts fetched by people building searchable podcast archives

Fetch transcripts with code

The same credits work from a script or an AI agent. The demo key returns a sample episode in full, no card needed:

request
curl -H "x-api-key: pt_demo" \
  https://spoken.md/transcripts/1000651996090

Markdown with the speakers named, for your notes, your knowledge base, or anything that makes HTTP calls.

From $0.10 per transcript. No subscription. Credits never expire. Prices exclude VAT, added at checkout for EU customers. Not what you expected? Email us within 14 days with 20 or fewer credits used and we refund the pack in full.

Using your own key:

request
curl -H "x-api-key: YOUR_KEY" \
  https://spoken.md/transcripts/1000800897806