Kane vs Shearer, Bruno's United Legacy & Our Best Community Questions | Stick to Football

**Gary Neville** (0:00)
Just before we get started, I just wanted to say a big thank you to our partner, Skybet. And please don't forget to subscribe if you like. I hope you enjoy this episode. Which teammate would you swap houses with for a week?

**Roy Keane** (0:12)
Hoses? The hosts are his situation.

**Jamie Carragher** (0:15)
No, no, no, don't do that, don't do that.

**Gary Neville** (0:18)
Have you ever changed your opinion about a player or a manager after meeting them personally?

**Jamie Carragher** (0:26)
Goal kick and you're going up for a header. You jump and I just stand, I don't jump at all. Is that a foul?

**Jamie Carragher** (0:32)
I don't need to foul.

**Jamie Carragher** (0:33)
You don't need to foul? I do.

**Gary Neville** (0:35)
Which player do you wish you played with more?

**Ian Wright** (0:37)
Maradona.

**Jamie Carragher** (0:39)
Oh, more than I didn't think.

**Ian Wright** (0:43)
That was for football reasons as well.

**Gary Neville** (0:50)
Right, Harry Kane is on the verge of becoming the quickest to score 100 goals in the Bundesliga. Rank these English strikers.
Harry Kane, Alan Shearer, Michael Owen, Wayne Rooney.

**Jill Scott** (1:03)
Oh, so difficult.

**Roy Keane** (1:05)
Silly one, isn't it?

**Ian Wright** (1:07)
All that does is cause problems and arguments.

**Roy Keane** (1:10)
So we have to pick an order, the best.

**Gary Neville** (1:12)
Yeah, I'm going to go Wayne Rooney is number one.

**Jill Scott** (1:13)
Wayne Rooney, yeah.

**Jamie Carragher** (1:15)
I'd class the others as more number nine.

**Ian Wright** (1:17)
Shearer number two.

**Jamie Carragher** (1:18)
No.

**Ian Wright** (1:19)
You're not putting Shearer over Harry Kane?

**Jamie Carragher** (1:22)
No.

**Gary Neville** (1:23)
Yeah, I am.

**Ian Wright** (1:23)
Yeah, I would and that's a solid one.

**Ian Wright** (1:27)
Are you doing it on how he plays his game?

**Jamie Carragher** (1:31)
I just think if they both say, let's say England's number nine.

**Gary Neville** (1:35)
Can we fix one at Wayne Rooney?

**Roy Keane** (1:36)
Can we fix Wayne Rooney there?

**Ian Wright** (1:38)
Wayne Rooney.

**Gary Neville** (1:38)
Can we fix Wayne Rooney?

**Ian Wright** (1:40)
Yeah.

**Gary Neville** (1:40)
Can we fix Michael Owen? He's a great player, Michael, but can we fix him at four?

**Jill Scott** (1:44)
Because of injuries.

**Ian Wright** (1:46)
Jamie, speak.

**Gary Neville** (1:47)
So it's Shearer and Kane then?

**Jamie Carragher** (1:48)
No, I get it and I think, I said this a few days ago, for me, I think Kane's English is great to strike it. Now, I don't class Wayne as a, when I'm thinking of that, I'm thinking of sort of like someone, the number nine, the goal scorer. I class Wayne as more of a great player rather than just the center forward. But I just think a lot of people would say Shearer over Kane, but I don't know what the actual, it'll just be, oh, I like him better.
His numbers are far better at an international level. He's been a top goal scorer at a World Cup. He's gone abroad and absolutely, I mean, he's played for one of the biggest clubs in the world, and he's absolutely smashing the records to bits. He's played for a top number who've never been the best team, and his record in the Premier Leagues is as good as Shearer's.

**Gary Neville** (2:28)
Alan was like that though, really.

**Ian Wright** (2:29)
Shearer, remember, Shearer went from Southampton to what he'd done at Blackburn.

**Jamie Carragher** (2:33)
I know, but he played for a Newcastle team who almost won the league one season, and then he signs the next season, so he's playing for one of the best teams in the league for two or three years at Newcastle. Blackburn were the top two teams for three years.

**Gary Neville** (2:45)
Carra, what about this as a compromise? I think for me, I would say that Shearer's number two and Kane's number three.

**Jamie Carragher** (2:50)
Okay, but what I'm saying is, what's your argument for that?

**Gary Neville** (2:53)
If Kane does, look, there's not much in it, to be fair, they're probably similar, but...

**Jamie Carragher** (2:58)
There's no argument, though, you're not giving me...

**Gary Neville** (3:00)
I think Shearer's the greatest goal scorer in Premier League history, and I think if Kane comes back...

**Jamie Carragher** (3:05)
But if Kane were to stay there, you're getting it.

**Gary Neville** (3:07)
No, and Kane could come back and do that, and we might be talking two, three years where we say Kane is above Shearer.

**Jamie Carragher** (3:11)
So Kane's got to come back and beat him in the Premier League goal scorer for Kane to go above?