Is end-to-end encryption really secure?

SPEAKER_1 (0:02)

Nordstrom brings you the season's most wanted brands. Skims, Mango, Free People, and Princess Polly, all under $100.

From trending sneakers to beauty must haves, we've curated the styles you'll wear on repeat this spring. Free shipping, free returns, and in-store pickup make it easier than ever. Shop now in stores and at nordstrom.com.

SPEAKER_2 (0:27)

At Lowe's, pros save big on the supplies you need to get the job done. With the new MyLowe's Pro Rewards Program, get member-only deals every week and access to free standard shipping. Plus, members earn points toward exclusive rewards. Join for free today. Lowe's, we help, you save. Points are awarded on eligible purchases, programs subject to terms and conditions, free standard shipping not available in Alaska and Hawaii, exclusions and more terms apply. Details at lowes.com/terms, subject to change.

Bababam (1:00)

Is end-to-end encryption really secure?

Thanks for asking.

In late April 2024, police chiefs from the UK's National Crime Agency and 32 European countries issued a statement expressing their concerns about the use of end-to-end encryption by instant messaging services like WhatsApp. The statement recognized that end-to-end encryption protects users' personal data, but emphasized that it also prevents authorities from identifying suspicious or illegal activities. And as we'll get to in just a moment, encryption doesn't always guarantee full privacy for users. What does end-to-end encryption actually mean in concrete terms? No doubt you'll have seen the term services like WhatsApp and Zoom in the past. Since the end of 2023, Messenger has also had end-to-end encryption. It basically means that no one else can intercept or access your conversations. When you hit send, your message is converted into an unreadable code during its journey from server to server. And it only becomes readable again when it reaches your recipient's device. It's kind of like sending your messages in a secure envelope that only your recipient can open.

Does that mean all my data is protected when I send a message then? Not entirely. In actual fact, end-to-end encryption doesn't mean everything is private. Let's take the example of Meta's messaging servers, which are used for messages sent via WhatsApp and Messenger. They still have access to Meta data, including information about who you've exchanged messages with and when. Since 2021, WhatsApp has also required users to accept the collection of certain personal data, such as their location, contact lists, and even photos, videos and audios shared via the platform. On the plus side, end-to-end encryption helps prevent some of your private information from falling into the wrong hands. Say you shared your address with a friend or family member via WhatsApp. You wouldn't want scammers or other dangerous people having access to that information, would you? But police authorities say that the more widespread end-to-end encryption becomes, the harder it will be for them to combat illegal activities and protect minors online. Commenting on the matter, National Crime Agency Director General Graham Bigger said, encryption can be hugely beneficial, protecting users from a range of crimes, but the blunt and increasingly widespread rollout by major tech companies of end-to-end encryption without sufficient consideration for public safety is putting users in danger. What's the best way to stay safe and secure then? It's a pretty complex issue. If you want to protect your conversations as much as possible, you should ideally avoid saving your chat histories in the cloud and use applications that don't collect metadata or rely on your phone number. One example is Signal, which you may remember we ran an episode on a while back. In short, balancing cyber security and privacy remains a challenge for now.

There you have it.

Now you know whether end-to-end encryption is really secure. In under three minutes, we answer your questions and help you understand the true meaning behind the trends, concepts and acronyms that are making headlines. Listen along and you will really know for sure.

SPEAKER_1 (4:47)

Ba ba ba.