Skip to content
How do I know when protection becomes overprotection? artwork

How do I know when protection becomes overprotection?

Pardon the Mess with Scarlet Hiltibidal - Christian Motherhood, Biblical Parenting, Raising Christian Kids

October 8, 2026

As moms, we want to protect our kids from pain, disappointment, failure, and suffering. But where is the line between helping our kids and keeping them from learning, growing, and trusting God for themselves?

Speakers Scarlet Hiltibidal, Christine Hoover

TopicsParentingKids & FamilyReligion & SpiritualityChristianity

Scarlet Hiltibidal (0:09)

Gift giving should feel like a joy, not a chore. But when life gets busy and the season gets loud, it's easy to lose that feeling. So, Christian Parenting put together the 2026 Christmas Gift Guide to help you get it back. One place filled with thoughtful gift ideas for everyone on your list. From faith-filled gifts and meaningful resources to cozy pajamas, beautiful sheets, gift boxes and kits. There's something for kids, parents, friends, teachers, and everyone in between. And beyond the gifts, we've also included some of our favorite Advent resources, family activities, devotionals for kids, and more to help you make the most of the season and keep Jesus at the center of your Christmas. So whether you're looking for something meaningful, something fun, or just a gift that makes someone feel really loved, we've got you covered. Head to christianparenting.org/christmas or grab the link in the episode description. Here's to a Christmas that's more meaningful and a whole lot less stressful.

Have you talked with your child about sex? Eventually, they will learn about it from someone, so leading the way as their parent is the right move, and it doesn't have to be awkward. Don't Stress Talking Sex is an age-specific resource that helps turn the talk into a healthy ongoing conversation. This book gives you the wisdom and talking points to help your kids navigate puberty and understand healthy sexuality. Don't Stress Talking Sex lowers anxiety and builds family trust. Get your copy wherever you buy books.

Thank you for And watching God's Word Together. Available wherever Bibles are sold.

Hello, and welcome back to Pardon the Mess. I'm your host Scarlett Hiltibidal. It's October. We're here. I'm ready to talk to you. I feel slightly insecure with this topic today because I have four kids and I'm just thinking back to my filter on this topic and I have changed so much as a mom, four kids in, and I feel like I definitely did this wrong from the get-go and but that's okay because here's the thing, we here at Pardon the Mess are not trying to be perfect moms. We are trying to point to a perfect Jesus and we're trying to talk through these things that feel messy and that feel unanswerable and we're trying to look at what God's Word has to say about it and learn from each other, right? So that's why I'm doing this topic. And I told you I'm a little insecure. It's funny because when I started this podcast, you know, if you are a longtime listener, this podcast has been around for years, but it was an interview-style podcast. And I switched it to topical. And of course, I started with my best topics, you guys.

I started with the things that I'm most comfortable talking about, that I feel like I've got a grip on, that I'm like, this is how I do it. And I feel really confident sharing this with moms. And I know it'll encourage them. But the thing about a podcast is they keep coming every week, you guys. Like, every week. I'm like, okay. Now, I do plan out my topics way far in advance. And I've had this on my list since the very beginning. But honestly, I kept bumping it down on the calendar because I'm like, man, do I have wisdom to share? Or am I just gonna share ways I've done it wrong? And I mean, here I go again. I've got an almost two-year-old. So, you know, how am I gonna do it this time? This is a tricky one, you guys. But I like to bring us the tricky ones because that's what we're here for, okay? We're gonna untangle this mess and talk about the question. I'll share a little bit. I've got a really great Messy Mom Moment, a really great guest who's gonna share her experience. Yeah, let me just tell you about her. Okay, guys, Christine Hoover. Have you heard of her? I've talked about her on this podcast. She's amazing. She is the author of a bunch of books. One of my favorites, You Are Not Forgotten. She's a Life Way Women Bible study author as well. So that's where I met her because I have some, I did Anxious and Ashamed with Life Way Women. And so we met at a Life Way Women author retreat. We'll talk more about that when I have her on. But we just instantly loved each other. I think she's amazing. She works in women's ministry at her church. And I just always love to read what she writes and hear what she has to say because I just love watching her walk with the Lord and she's just, I just like her a lot. So I'm happy to introduce her to you if you haven't already met her. But anyway, okay, so protection versus overprotection. This is what we're talking about today, you guys. You know, my excuse for seasons where I've done it wrong has always been, well, you know, I was adopted by a SWAT cop. How am I supposed to be as a mom? Of course, I'm going to be overprotective. With my first kid who is 15 now, oh my goodness. I was helicopter mom to the maximum. I have definitely cooled off on that over time.

33 more minutes of transcript below

Thousands of transcripts fetched by people building searchable podcast archives

Fetch the whole transcript

The demo key returns a sample episode in full, no card needed:

request
curl -H "x-api-key: pt_demo" \
  https://spoken.md/transcripts/1000651996090

Markdown with the speakers named, for your notes, your knowledge base, or anything that makes HTTP calls.

From $0.10 per transcript. No subscription. Credits never expire. Prices exclude VAT, added at checkout for EU customers. Not what you expected? Email us within 14 days with 20 or fewer credits used and we refund the pack in full.

Using your own key:

request
curl -H "x-api-key: YOUR_KEY" \
  https://spoken.md/transcripts/1000793813255