Farwell's Defense Claims THIS About Sandra Birchmore
Hidden Killers With Tony Brueski | True Crime News & Commentary
September 11, 2026
The defense in the Matthew Farwell case is building its strategy around Sandra Birchmore's mental health records, her journals, and her history of instability. They want the jury to see a woman who killed herself.
Speakers Tony Brueski
TopicsTrue CrimeNewsNews Commentary
Tony Brueski (0:00)
This is HiddenKillers With Tony Brueski.
SPEAKER_2 (0:10)
Because Massachusetts seems to be a hotspot these days for criminal activity in large cases, let's go there. Let's revisit. We're going to go to the Sandra Birchmore case, the one that's not too far away from Canton, not too far away from Karen Reed country, in fact, actually involves some of the same officers from that case, believe it or not. Matthew Farwell's defense team is going to be walking into a federal courtroom on October 5th, unless something changes between now and then, and tell a jury that Sandra Birchmore was unstable. That's what's coming, mark my words. We're going to be going through what they're going to pitch, very likely, in that courtroom, and how, how to understand that information, how to process that information, because it's going to be pitched and molded and mental gymnastic in such a way over here, that when it reaches the courtroom, one may go, huh, that's an interesting point. But when you understand how things were molded and how it got into that mental gymnastic state in the world of Sandra Birchmore, you know, oh, oh, well, you fuck faces did that to her. That's why she's the way she is. That's why she operates the way she operates. Because you conceded self-serving mutants on the Canton Police Force that were preying on her since she was a child. Huh, you really kind of gave her a solid example when she was looking to authority figures about how to be manipulative, how to control people, how to lie, how to do all those sorts of things.
While you were violating her repeatedly, and passing her around like a piece of meat, you know, she's just a broken child.
It's a disgusting case, and we're here to expose every inch of it, and the motherfuckers who are behind it. So those of you who are incarcerated with people like Farwell, you know all about him. So when he comes your way, you can sharpen your broomsticks, and just know, there is cash coming to your canteen very soon. I'm not insinuating anything, I'm not asking for anything, I'm just saying that seems to be how the universe works. People take out horrible human beings in prison, cash magically appears in people's canteens from thousands of people across the country following the case, going, ha! You eliminated a scum bucket from the planet, you get extra snickers. Again, not encouraging that, not saying anyone should do that, just saying, it seems that's how the universe works a lot. So, if you're watching this on your iPad from prison, let's learn about Matthew Farwell and his buddies, and the horrific manipulation, coercion, abuse, and murder that was brought upon Sandra Birchmore by people wearing the badge.
Your thoughts on the comment section as we do them. Substack, YouTube, links are in the description.
So, assuming this trial goes forward, whenever it does, right now it's set for October 5th, they're gonna go into that courtroom, and they're gonna tell you, and they're gonna tell the jury, that Sandra Birchmore was unstable, that she was manipulative, that she had a history of mental illness stretching back from age 9, a prior attempt on her own life, a journal entry. She was contemplating ending it. They will present a medication prescribed 12 days before her death that carries an S warning. They'll present her search history, her psychiatric record, and her own handwritten words as proof that she did this to herself.
And look, some of that's gonna be true. Sandra Birchmore was unstable. She did manipulate, she did lie. I'm not here to pretend any of that's not true. It is. But the defense is counting on the jury, never asking the next question. Which is, how a girl gets this way? Sandra Birchmore walked into Stoughton Police Explorers, at 12 years old, looking for a father figure. What she found were men in uniform, who used her for the next decade. Every behavior the defense plans to put in front of that jury traces straight back to what those men did to her. The man at the defense table was the first one through the door. The defense will call Sandra manipulative. Here's her evidence. In October 2020, she drafted a message to Farwell's wife, threatening to expose their relationship. And instead of sending it, prosecutors say she turned it into a deal. Farwell would try to conceive a child with her. In return, she'd keep the secret. The defense will frame that as a woman running a scheme. But Sandra was 23 when she made that play. And she been under Farwell's control since she was 15 Some accounts say even younger. Prosecutors allege she tracked her phone location, told her to delete text, swore. Hurt to secrecy and use violence against her as punishment for nearly a decade. She didn't learn to bargain with secrets in a vacuum. She learned it from the man who built the entire relationship on one condition. Silence. The defense will call Sandra unstable. Their evidence? Psychiatric treatment beginning at age 9 The loss of her mother and grandmother while she was still a teenager. Journal entries where she contemplated ending it. They won the right to present all of it. What the defense won't volunteer is what was happening to Sandra during those same years while she was in school mourning her mother trying to hold her life together. Matthew Farwell, a 27-year-old police officer, was allegedly meeting her in his patrol car. Prosecutors say he crossed the line with her when she was 15 Text messages recovered by the FBI show of acknowledging he was her first, and writing that he wished it had happened sooner.
11 more minutes of transcript below
Thousands of transcripts fetched by people building searchable podcast archives
Feed this to your agent
Try it now — copy, paste, done:
curl -H "x-api-key: pt_demo" \
https://spoken.md/transcripts/1000651996090Works with Claude, ChatGPT, Cursor, and any agent that makes HTTP calls.
From $0.10 per transcript. No subscription. Credits never expire. Prices exclude VAT, added at checkout for EU customers. Not what you expected? Email us within 14 days with 20 or fewer credits used and we refund the pack in full.
Using your own key:
curl -H "x-api-key: YOUR_KEY" \
https://spoken.md/transcripts/1000788980562