DOGE Cut the Civil Service by 12% | Judge Glock artwork

DOGE Cut the Civil Service by 12% | Judge Glock

MTS

October 22, 2026

Judge Glock of the Manhattan Institute counters the popular view that DOGE failed, arguing that its 12% reduction of the civil service (270,000 workers) represents the fastest federal workforce decline since World War II.

0:00

Judge Glock

The Federal Civil Service lost about 270,000 people. The workforce is 12% smaller than it was before, the fastest decline since World War II.

And despite every one of the media desperately trying to find stories about the federal government falling apart, in fact, it's operating pretty much like it did before.

0:20

Thea

And we're back, we're live with Judge Glock, who is Director of Research and a Senior Fellow at the Manhattan Institute, a Contributing Editor at City Journal. I love the Manhattan Institute, really, it's one of the best think tanks out there.

So Judge, welcome back to MTS.

0:37

Judge Glock

Thanks so much for having me, and I agree about the Manhattan Institute.

0:40

Thea

So you wrote this article recently called DOGE Achieved More Than You Think. This is sort of contrary to popular wisdom, which is that DOGE was a very loud and very public entity that ultimately kind of failed in its goals, it didn't reduce government spending.

For example, so what's your counter take to this?

1:01

Judge Glock

So yeah, the usual take in the media is that Elon came in, promised trillions of dollars of savings and came up woefully short because he fundamentally didn't understand how government worked, that most of the spending was mandatory, so security entitlements, etc.

And to some level, I give credit to that view. Like Elon and a lot of the team was not versed in the intricacies of government. They did not understand it was going to be impossible to cut the level of spending they hope to. But I think the important corollary is if you don't judge them relative to those claims, you judge them relative to what they actually accomplished, well, then it looks pretty reasonable. I show contracts and grants they targeted went down. And most importantly, by far, the Federal Civil Service lost about 270,000 people, the workforce is 12% smaller than it was before, the fastest decline since World War II. And despite every one of the media desperately trying to find stories about the Federal Government falling apart, in fact, it's operating pretty much like it did before.

2:04

Thea

Interesting. So how did you come to this conclusion in the first place?

2:11

Judge Glock

So yeah, I mean, I actually happened to be a little bit suspicious about DOGE circa mid 2025 I had heard the insane claims about their cuts. I had heard the descriptions of how little they were actually able to accomplish and how kind of the DOGE charts often had errors about how much they saved in some particular contract or another.

Like some other people even, I shared some of those charts that showed, look, federal spending is continuing to go up just like it did the year before and the year before. But then, earlier this year, I started to look and you say, wait a second, if you really cut the federal civil service by 12 percent, by hundreds of thousands of people, and I really haven't heard a credible story about how bad the government has functioned because of the cuts since then, well, that seems like a pretty big deal to me. Then I just went into the numbers and looked like a lot of what we heard about DOGE and the civil service just isn't true. I think, for instance, a lot of people think of DOGE as well, it was just a way to get back at agencies that Trump didn't like, like USAID.

Where were the biggest cuts in the civil service? Department of War. 80,000 fewer civil servants than there were before. It's not because they hated the Department of War. They've spent more on it before. It's just the actual white collar workforce is smaller. And again, I don't think that's done any detriment to the actual function in the people on the front lines and people haven't been able to find that story if it has.

3:41

Thea

Totally.

And I mean, it definitely reminds me a lot of 2022 when Elon acquired Twitter and then proceeded to fire. I think it was 80% of Twitter's workforce. And all of the very smart people at the time were like, oh, yeah, I mean, this is going to completely destroy Twitter. Like the website is just going to stop functioning. It's going to stop running. And that did not happen at all. They predicted that everyone important would flee to Macedon and blue sky and threads. That did not happen at all. I mean, it happened a little bit, but not really. And many of the people have since come back.

And they predicted that the overall experience of the website would be significantly worse than before the acquisition. And some people agree with this. I happen to disagree with it. But I think the growth speaks for itself. Like Twitter ended up being fine, if not better than before.

Read the other 12 minutes of this episode here.

$15 gets you this episode and 99 more. Credits never expire. After checkout, one link brings you back here to read it.

Not what you expected? Full refund within 14 days.

Thousands of transcripts fetched by people building searchable podcast archives

Fetch transcripts with code

The same credits work from a script or an AI agent. The demo key returns a sample episode in full, no card needed:

request
curl -H "x-api-key: pt_demo" \
  https://spoken.md/transcripts/1000651996090

Markdown with the speakers named, for your notes, your knowledge base, or anything that makes HTTP calls.

From $0.10 per transcript. No subscription. Credits never expire. Prices exclude VAT, added at checkout for EU customers. Not what you expected? Email us within 14 days with 20 or fewer credits used and we refund the pack in full.

Using your own key:

request
curl -H "x-api-key: YOUR_KEY" \
  https://spoken.md/transcripts/1000797547048