California Spending Is Up 72% Since 2019 | Joshua Rauh
MTS
November 7, 2026
Stanford finance professor Joshua Rauh breaks down why California’s proposed Prop 40 billionaire wealth tax faces low odds and threatens to accelerate capital flight.
Joshua Rauh
The state of California has got a lot of money right now, but if you look at how much money the state of California is spending, you know, in its current budget, relative to 2019, it's up 72% since 2019 If you just look at how much money the state's actually bringing in, and localities as well, it doesn't seem like there's a revenue problem, it seems like there's a spending problem.
Theo
And we're back with our next guest, Colin, Joshua Rauh, who is the Orman family professor of finance at Stanford GSB Graduate School of Business, and a senior fellow in economics at the Hoover Institution, where he leads the state and local government initiative, which is very topical because we have a lot of state and local government initiatives right now.
Ballot initiatives like, for example, the California wealth tax. So it will be great to talk about it on MTS. Welcome.
Joshua Rauh
Thanks so much, Theo. Great to be with you.
Theo
So tell us about the Prop 40, the one time supposedly 5% tax on billionaires, which only has a 26% chance of passing on Cal-She, which seems very low given what we know about the state of California politically.
It was never above 50%. So why is that?
Joshua Rauh
Well, this is probably the single state ballot proposition that is being watched the most across the country, and actually probably around the world. I've talked to people in Europe and France. They're saying we're looking to see whether the United States is going to go down this path of taxing wealth.
You asked, why is it that Cal-She is only showing a 25 to 30% chance of it getting passed? Well, first of all, this is a tax proposition on the ballot. California has other ones. Lots of tax propositions on ballots around the country. This is a tax increase that is actually opposed by Gavin Newsom, Democratic governor of the state of California, and also by the California Teacher's Association. So, I gotta say, I think that's one reason why the polls have been kind of around 50-50. It's sort of hard to say.
But I think that's one reason why people are predicting that it might not succeed. What is this thing? All right. It's a 5 percent tax on the wealth of anyone with more than a billion dollars. So, this is a wealth tax. It's not an income tax. We already have an income tax. But the architects of this wealth tax are of the view that the income tax is insufficient to tax the wealth of billionaires. They're of the view that billionaires don't pay enough of their wealth each year in taxes even though they do pay very significant income taxes at both the state and federal level. So, they put this in and they said, we're going to do a one-time, one-time, they're promising, one-time tax of 5 percent.
What's happened is the number of billionaires actually have left state of California because they're concerned that maybe this one-time won't be so one-time. It's hard to actually get any kind of commitment. Is there any real commitment that it's only going to be one-time? No. I would say, there's nothing, there's a famous quote in my field of economics that there's nothing so permanent as a temporary government program. I and some other tax economists like to twist that around. There's nothing so permanent as a temporary tax. And most tax dollars can be introduced. They're called temporary, but they often get made permanent, including California's high-bracket marginal income tax rates, by the way.
Theo
Right.
So it seems like this will probably not pass. And even if it does pass, it can be overridden, I believe, by either of Prop 41 or 42 or by courts or something. So CalSheet predicts that it's only like a 10 percent chance of actually being enacted by January 1st. But regardless of this, if Democrats win both houses of Congress and the presidency in 2028, what do you think are the prospects for a potential national wealth tax? Like Senator Elizabeth Warren, for example, has proposed a 2 percent wealth tax on all net worth annually, on all net worth above 50 million and 6 percent on all net worth above 1 billion.
Joshua Rauh
They are definitely talking about this. And what's going on in California right now, it's really just foreshadowing the discussion that we're going to have on the national level about this. I think for a lot of your MTS viewers, one of the, I think, very important aspects of these wealth taxes to pay attention to, is the fact that they tax intangible wealth, and that includes the value of startups, of enterprises. The California one actually, Prop 40, is very clear that it taxes it based on the implied owner share, the post-money valuation of any company. What does that mean practically?
Read the other 7 minutes of this episode here.
$15 gets you this episode and 99 more. Credits never expire. After checkout, one link brings you back here to read it.
Not what you expected? Full refund within 14 days.
Thousands of transcripts fetched by people building searchable podcast archives
Fetch transcripts with code
The same credits work from a script or an AI agent. The demo key returns a sample episode in full, no card needed:
curl -H "x-api-key: pt_demo" \
https://spoken.md/transcripts/1000651996090Markdown with the speakers named, for your notes, your knowledge base, or anything that makes HTTP calls.
From $0.10 per transcript. No subscription. Credits never expire. Prices exclude VAT, added at checkout for EU customers. Not what you expected? Email us within 14 days with 20 or fewer credits used and we refund the pack in full.
Using your own key:
curl -H "x-api-key: YOUR_KEY" \
https://spoken.md/transcripts/1000800458941