Skip to content
Rewind with Karen & Georgia - 119: Fingers Everywhere artwork

Rewind with Karen & Georgia - 119: Fingers Everywhere

My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

October 14, 2026

It's time to Rewind with Karen & Georgia! This week, K & G recap Episode 119: Fingers Everywhere. Georgia covered William Heirens, the “Lipstick Killer,” and Karen discussed the Lindbergh baby kidnapping. Tune in for all-new commentary, case updates and more!

Speakers Georgia Hardstark, Karen Kilgariff

TopicsTrue Crime

Georgia Hardstark (0:18)

And welcome to Rewind with Karen and Georgia.

Karen Kilgariff (0:21)

This is the show where we look back on our old episodes from 2018 with all new insights and case updates and topical cultural references.

Georgia Hardstark (0:29)

Today we're rewinding to episode 119, which we named Fingers Everywhere. This episode originally came out on May 3rd, 2018

Karen Kilgariff (0:40)

Let's listen to the intro of episode 119 Hello and welcome.

Georgia Hardstark (0:48)

Hi, welcome.

Karen Kilgariff (0:50)

Are you saying that to me?

Georgia Hardstark (0:51)

I'm reiterating.

Karen Kilgariff (0:52)

Oh, because welcome to you.

Georgia Hardstark (0:54)

Welcome to you, Karen.

Karen Kilgariff (0:55)

Thank you.

Georgia Hardstark (0:55)

And everyone to My Favorite Murder, the podcast.

Karen Kilgariff (0:59)

This is a podcast where we talk about true crime, you know, and everything else under the sun.

Georgia Hardstark (1:04)

Everything we can even imagine.

Karen Kilgariff (1:06)

Oh, my God, we're getting into a lot of religious stuff lately. Spirituality.

Georgia Hardstark (1:12)

I'm more spiritual than religious. I'm not religious, I'm more spiritual. No, but I hear people saying that on dates behind me at restaurants all the time, and I just want to punch them in the face.

Karen Kilgariff (1:21)

I'd love to sit behind a date where they were like, I am strictly religious and I think spirituality is wrong. I'm here for the rules in the books, and I don't care about the soul or the feeling.

Georgia Hardstark (1:34)

I would be relieved to hear that. In LA, you'll never hear that in LA.

Karen Kilgariff (1:41)

I feel like in LA, I witness so many Tinder dates or coffee meetups, and I get so involved.

Georgia Hardstark (1:51)

Oh, like how?

Karen Kilgariff (1:53)

Well, I'm a humongous eavesdropper. I'll eavesdrop on anybody.

Georgia Hardstark (1:56)

Me too. How can you not?

It's not eavesdropping, it's listening to the conversation going on. That is going on way too loudly.

Karen Kilgariff (2:03)

Always, because it's a city full of actors, and everybody thinks they should be heard.

Georgia Hardstark (2:09)

But then they're talking about stuff that they think is unique and interesting, like us, for example, in this podcast. Like, true crime.

Karen Kilgariff (2:18)

Why talk about it if you're not going to record it?

Georgia Hardstark (2:20)

Like this murder.

Karen Kilgariff (2:21)

You know what makes me? It's because I have a problem with vulnerability. So when two people are sitting in front of each other, trying to present themselves as, here's my most interesting, it makes me want to vomit into the closest garbage can for seven hours.

Georgia Hardstark (2:35)

I'm sorry, the garbage can, because there's also a composting can and there's also a recycling and there's also the coffee place I go to has a an area to put your like coffee sleeve in to recycle the sleeve.

Karen Kilgariff (2:47)

Oh, OK.

Georgia Hardstark (2:47)

Which I think has to be definitely against health codes. But I do it anyways.

Karen Kilgariff (2:52)

Oh, well, my first of all, my vomit would definitely go into composting. Sure, because that's just going to churn up all the plastic bottles. The acid is going to break down all of those egg shells.

Georgia Hardstark (3:03)

Because every place you go into here has three bins and you sit there and stare at them. And I'm going on a tirade. Go on.

Karen Kilgariff (3:10)

Three bins, 17 actors. Everybody's trying to hook up.

Georgia Hardstark (3:14)

Yeah.

Karen Kilgariff (3:15)

And yeah. And then if you want to reuse a coffee sleeve. Wait now, is that voluntary or are they just going to reuse those coffee sleeves? You don't know about it as the person buying what you think is a new coffee with a new sleeve.

Georgia Hardstark (3:29)

I bet. I bet you think it's new and it's not new.

Karen Kilgariff (3:33)

You think that's true?

Georgia Hardstark (3:34)

With their dirty fingers all over it?

Karen Kilgariff (3:36)

No.

Georgia Hardstark (3:36)

I'd rather burn my fingers.

Karen Kilgariff (3:37)

Your fingers are where you put, you put your fingers everywhere.

Georgia Hardstark (3:41)

I put my fingers everywhere.

Karen Kilgariff (3:42)

Do you know? Do you know? Yeah.

Georgia Hardstark (3:44)

You know that about me.

Karen Kilgariff (3:45)

I'm confronting you. That's how I meant that sentence.

Georgia Hardstark (3:48)

You've been on tour with me.

Karen Kilgariff (3:50)

I meant to say stop putting your fingers everywhere.

Georgia Hardstark (3:53)

Oh, shit. Okay. All right.

Karen Kilgariff (3:56)

Speaking of which, and I'm sorry for the segue, someone started a hashtag, Hot For Holes, and it is wrong. It's filthy.

126 more minutes of transcript below

Thousands of transcripts fetched by people building searchable podcast archives

Fetch the whole transcript

The demo key returns a sample episode in full, no card needed:

request
curl -H "x-api-key: pt_demo" \
  https://spoken.md/transcripts/1000651996090

Markdown with the speakers named, for your notes, your knowledge base, or anything that makes HTTP calls.

From $0.10 per transcript. No subscription. Credits never expire. Prices exclude VAT, added at checkout for EU customers. Not what you expected? Email us within 14 days with 20 or fewer credits used and we refund the pack in full.

Using your own key:

request
curl -H "x-api-key: YOUR_KEY" \
  https://spoken.md/transcripts/1000796264833