Jazz Chisholm Jr. Instagram Feud Highlights Yankees Playoff Disaster
The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle
October 6, 2026
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle analyze the Yankees' disastrous defensive display and historic offensive struggles in the postseason. They address Jazz Chisholm Jr. responding to fans on social media and the lack of fundamental play during the critical series against the Rays.
Speakers Craig Carton, Chris McMonigle
TopicsSports
Craig Carton (0:30)
And it's hard to argue against that, by the way.
Chris McMonigle (0:32)
Listen, I'm going to be the... I'm not the... I saw this coming.
Craig Carton (0:37)
I feel like you were.
Chris McMonigle (0:39)
No, I'm apoplectic, I'm pissed off.
Craig Carton (0:41)
But you didn't see it coming.
Chris McMonigle (0:42)
I didn't see it last night.
SPEAKER_3 (0:43)
You thought this team would be different.
Chris McMonigle (0:44)
You thought four... Again, this isn't the same as it's been. I know, that happened once. This didn't happen last year. There's no hitting I saw coming.
Not scoring enough runs I saw coming. Making three errors in the first four batters, I did not see coming.
Craig Carton (0:58)
I don't think anyone saw that coming. And especially the McMonigle, it's like a lazy line drive to them.
Chris McMonigle (1:03)
This team has been better defensively. They're not great, but they've been better defensively and they stressed it. They told us this is their focus.
They're making decisions based on playing the better defensive players. And it's still happening.
Craig Carton (1:18)
Not just that, they made a point during the broadcast and it's nice to say that the Yankees in between the two games worked on bunt defense. Most teams don't do that that much in the playoffs during the season. And they spend hours, I guess, working on their bunt defense.
Chris McMonigle (1:36)
And look, this isn't an excuse, but that ballpark is a freaking disaster.
Craig Carton (1:41)
Yeah, that's not why they lost, though.
Chris McMonigle (1:42)
No, but...
Craig Carton (1:43)
No, I don't want to hear about that. I don't want to hear about the ballpark.
SPEAKER_3 (1:45)
The Rays played at their ballpark.
Craig Carton (1:46)
Ballpark had nothing to do with the Yankees losing. The Yankees, who are the Yankees' loss? I don't want to hear you.
The soft line drive to McMan.
SPEAKER_3 (1:55)
That ain't a ballpark.
Chris McMonigle (1:56)
No, it's off the ground.
Craig Carton (1:57)
Yeah, but it essentially came to him as a line drive, off the hop.
Chris McMonigle (2:00)
Yeah.
Craig Carton (2:00)
Right? He put his back hand up, whoop, right past him. What happened?
Chris McMonigle (2:04)
I don't know. And then, do you see his look? He's like, I don't know what just happened.
Craig Carton (2:07)
Yeah. He actually looked at the glove like there was a hole in that Wilson A2000 glove.
Chris McMonigle (2:12)
I don't know.
Craig Carton (2:12)
And I don't know, because they showed the glove. I felt bad for Wilson. They're like, no, no, our gloves usually work.
It's Nick in Middletown.
Chris McMonigle (2:21)
What a nightmare.
Craig Carton (2:22)
I'm the fan. Nicky, how are you doing today, pal?
SPEAKER_3 (2:25)
What's up, fellas? Thanks for taking the call. Love the show.
Craig Carton (2:28)
All right.
SPEAKER_3 (2:30)
So my buddy Rob, diehard Yankees fan, he messages Jazz after the game, like a psycho, and Jazz responds on Instagram. So I wanted to share that with you and get your thoughts.
Craig Carton (2:41)
I'd love to hear. What did he write to Jazz first?
SPEAKER_3 (2:46)
So he sends Jazz the Webster definition of fundamentals. Then he says, just wanted to give you the definition of what fundamentals mean because it's incredibly clear that you lack in that area when it comes to the game of baseball.
So Jazz responds and says, that's why you play on the Yankees and I don't, huh? Crying face.
Craig Carton (3:12)
Ha, so he told a joke. Look at Jazz Chisholm laughing after a game.
SPEAKER_3 (3:17)
This guy's a loser.
Craig Carton (3:20)
He's not going to be a Yankee after tomorrow. That's possible.
Chris McMonigle (3:24)
I mean, I hear you, but like he shouldn't have even responded.
SPEAKER_3 (3:27)
But like, you know, I mean, see Mac, you're the smartest Yankee fan in the tri stage.
Craig Carton (3:32)
Wow.
SPEAKER_3 (3:32)
This guy commits this guy commits 30 errors. You know, the reason why they lost and he takes the Instagram after the game and responds to my moron friend Rob.
Chris McMonigle (3:42)
I agree.
SPEAKER_3 (3:42)
What are we doing?
Craig Carton (3:43)
He should be responding to morons or to anybody else on Instagram.
Chris McMonigle (3:47)
Should not be responded to.
Craig Carton (3:48)
But I wonder why Moron Rob didn't send that same message to McMahon. Yeah, or to Lombard or to Grisham or to anybody else. Yeah, the Yankees collectively played like they had never played Toma Mansky baseball videos before.
Chris McMonigle (4:04)
It was right.
Craig Carton (4:07)
Because I'm not saying you missed out on a diving stop or, oh my God, you physically overthrew a cutoff man.
22 more minutes of transcript below
Thousands of transcripts fetched by people building searchable podcast archives
Fetch the whole transcript
The demo key returns a sample episode in full, no card needed:
curl -H "x-api-key: pt_demo" \
https://spoken.md/transcripts/1000651996090Markdown with the speakers named, for your notes, your knowledge base, or anything that makes HTTP calls.
From $0.10 per transcript. No subscription. Credits never expire. Prices exclude VAT, added at checkout for EU customers. Not what you expected? Email us within 14 days with 20 or fewer credits used and we refund the pack in full.
Using your own key:
curl -H "x-api-key: YOUR_KEY" \
https://spoken.md/transcripts/1000793509710