IDBI Bank is finally being sold

Saad (0:01)

Hello folks, you're tuned in to Finshots Daily. I'm Saad. If you're new here, welcome. If you're returning, welcome back. In today's episode, we break down the Fairfax-IDBI Bank Daily.

Before we head to the story, here's a quick word from Team Ditto. We're hosting a free two-day insurance masterclass that helps you build real financial security by understanding health and life insurance the right way. Right from understanding how to protect your family, choosing the right cover amount, and knowing what truly matters during a claim, to how hospitals process claims, the mistakes bios usually make, and how to choose a policy that won't disappoint you when you need it the most. We will explain it all in plain language. Head to the link in the description and save your spot. Now to the story. The last time we wrote about the IDBI Bank was in 2022, and back then, we asked a rather perplexing question. When will the IDBI saga end?

You see, almost every year, there were talks about the government selling its stake in the bank to meet its divestment targets. Sometimes, potential buyers showed interest. Sometimes, negotiations even began. But the sale would always get stuck. Either the buyers couldn't meet the regulatory conditions, or the government wasn't happy with the price they were offering. But now it looks like all of that might have finally ended. The day before yesterday, the government approved the sale of a majority stake in IDBI Bank to a Toronto-based company called Fairfax for 52,878 crore rupees in cash.

Once the deal goes through, Fairfax will control 60.72% of the bank.

This stake currently belongs to the government and LIC, whose respective holdings will fall to 15% and 19% after the sale. And that would also make this the largest foreign direct investment, or FDI, in India's financial sector.

Sidebar, Indian FDI rules allow foreign companies to own up to 74% of a private sector bank, so Fairfax can acquire a majority stake. But RBI rules require it to eventually reduce its promoter holding to 26%.

It will have 15 years to do this after a 5-year lock-in period ends. Of course, the deal isn't done just yet. It needs approvals from RBI and SEBI, among others. Fairfax will also have to make an open offer, giving IDBI Bank's minority shareholders an opportunity to sell their shares. But assuming that the deal goes through, let's understand why Fairfax wants to bet on IDBI Bank in the first place. To do that, we need to know a little bit about Fairfax.

Officially called Fairfax Financial Holdings, it's an insurance and investment company founded and run by Prem Watsa. Its business model relies on something called Float.

Basically, insurers collect premiums from customers first and pay claims later. In the meantime, they can invest that money and earn returns, much like Warren Buffet's Berkshire Hathwaiters. And Fairfax has been putting that money to work in India for a while now. It owns significant stakes in Bengaluru International Airport, Thomas Cook India, IIFL, GoTijit, General Insurance and CSB Bank, formerly the Catholic Syrian Bank. It also owned a stake in ICICI Lombard a few years ago before selling it. That brings us to IDBI Bank. IDBI is much bigger than CSB Bank in terms of business, profits and branch network. For Fairfax, this means an access to a much larger network through which it could potentially distribute its financial products. Of course, you might wonder whether Fairfax can control two banks at the same time, and you'd be right. Under RBI rules, it cannot simply keep controlling stakes in both indefinitely. So it may eventually have to either exit CSB Bank or merge its banking, IIFL capital and insurance businesses into a single entity, depending on whatever is more beneficial. The broader idea, though, is to build a powerful financial business, offering loans, gold loans, insurance and deposits. And the thing is, Fairfax might be getting this opportunity at a reasonable price. To put that into perspective, it's paying roughly nine times IDBI's FY26 profits of ₹9,513 crore. The price per share is also only about 23% above the bank's book value, or net assets, assets minus liabilities, of ₹65.75 per share. And roughly 7% above the average estimated fair value of ₹76 per share. Most importantly, the offer price is slightly below what the stock is trading at in the market. And this is where we start to see a few challenges that the deal faces. We say this because after the government approved the deal, it attracted some displeasure from IDBI Bank's Employees Forum. They aren't sure whether the bank has been valued fairly and they are asking for evidence that the bank isn't being undersold. Well, their skepticism may not just stem from the fact that IDBI is being sold for less than its market value. It could also be that over the past decade, the bank has improved its financial health considerably, partly after the government infused capital into it. For instance, its gross non-performing assets or NPAs, which are loans that have stopped being repaid after a prolonged period of 90 days, fell from 31.8% in 2018 to just 2.3% in 2026 Net NPAs have also declined significantly, and the bank's ability to absorb unexpected losses has improved, while its capital adequacy ratio rising from 6.2% to 26.7% over the same period. So the Employees Forum may be looking at the bank's turnaround and wondering whether the offer adequately reflects how much it has improved. But the government has its own reasons for believing that the price isn't unfair. For starters, it argues that comparing Fairfax's offer with IDBI's current market price isn't the best way to judge the deal. That's because the bank's shares had nearly tripled since the government first announced its plans to sell its stake. Investors may have been anticipating a takeover and hyping up the stock before an actual buyer committed to the deal. Another thing to consider is that LIC and the government still hold 94.72% of IDBI Bank between them. That means only a small portion of the bank's shares are in public hands. And when a stock has very few shares being traded, even a small purchase can push its price up significantly. That's something that has been happening for a while, whenever the government's plans to sell IDBI Bank came up. The problem is that this could make the stock price a poor reflection of IDBI Bank's actual worth. Which is why the government says it didn't use the market price as a benchmark to value the bank. Instead, it consulted two independent valuers who looked at the bank's worth using two methods. First, was the market multiple method, which looks at measures such as price to earnings ratio and enterprise value to EBIT. The second was asset valuation method, which considers the bank's net asset value. That said, the valuation isn't the only open question surrounding the deal. There's another potential clash, if you want to call it that, over how LIC and Fairfax distribute their insurance products through IDBI Bank. Because you see, even after the deal goes through, LIC will continue to hold a small stake in the bank. And IDBI Bank has been one of LIC's key bank assurance partners, helping it sell insurance policies to the bank's customers. But you also have to remember that Fairfax also owns GoDigit General Insurance. So once it takes control of IDBI, could LIC possibly face competition from another insurance company through the same banking channel it has relied on? That's something we'll have to wait and see. Thank you so much for joining, folks. I'll see you soon.