How good is Antonelli compared to Verstappen? artwork

How good is Antonelli compared to Verstappen?

The Race F1 Podcast

October 27, 2026

Top of the pile is a question about how champion elect Kimi Antonelli compares to Max Verstappen, which is followed by another about how the Italian has improved as a driver in 2026.

0:02

Edd Straw

The Athletic.

The race is on, and in today's Mailbag episode, we answer questions on how Kimi Antonelli compares to Max Verstappen, whether talk of Lewis Hamilton being back to his best in 2026 was premature, why some race incidents take so long to be investigated, and much more. I'm Ed Straw, and joining me with all the answers is Josh Suttill. Welcome to The Race F1 Podcast, sponsored by Skinceuticals. Josh, great to have you here for another Mailbag, and thanks to everybody who sent in Mailbag questions. We always invite those from The Race Members Club for our post-race review podcasts, and also that feeds this show. So if you remember when you do that, if you put Mailbag in the question text somewhere, that's very, very useful if you think it's more of a midweek one than an immediate post-race one. But Josh, we're here in Austin, we're heading to Mexico shortly. So a nice chance to look back a little bit at some of the questions still arising from goings on at the weekend.

1:06

Josh Suttill

Absolutely. It was quite a storied weekend actually. I mean, maybe it wasn't the most absolutely thrilling race, but there was actually a decent amount of stories to follow up on.

1:14

Edd Straw

There absolutely were. So without further ado, let's have a look at what we've got. The first question from Motorsport Mike, how good is Kimi Antonelli compared to Max Verstappen? The first year they have a car capable of winning a title, they deliver. Potentially, Antonelli hasn't wrapped it up yet. Well, I think we can take that as a foregone conclusion for now, but interesting question.

1:34

Josh Suttill

Yeah, definitely. When I'm very interested to get your take on as well.

It's certainly at the moment, I think actually quite close between them, which is a big surprise because for me, Verstappen has been the benchmark driver in F1, probably maybe since 2021, I'd say that felt like maybe the change over period. Lewis Hamilton before then was in my mind the benchmark driver. Felt like it was sort of wrestled off him by Verstappen. In that title fight, they were both at the top of the game. And certainly in the ground effect era, I think there was zero doubt that Verstappen was the benchmark driver. But yeah, Antonelli has been that good, but actually I think that question is actually now, that is now a question rather than a fact, who is the benchmark driver? So it's certainly looking close between them and they feel like in a band of two really at the top when you're looking at the quality of them.

2:21

Edd Straw

Yeah, I think if you say who is the best driving driver in Formula 1 today, it's still Max Verstappen. He is outstandingly good. One of the absolute greatest of all time. Antonelli much earlier in his career. It's difficult to compare the first title years because they are so different. Max Verstappen came into Formula 1 in 2015

His first title shot wasn't until 2021 Antonelli's done it in his second year. But without the intense title fight, the back and forth with Lewis Hamilton, another all time great that Verstappen had. So I think the first titles are very, very difficult to compare because there's so many parameters that are different. But I think Antonelli has undoubtedly, in fact, established himself as one of those gold standard drivers in Formula 1 There's no doubt whatsoever about that. So he's comparable with Verstappen at this stage. It's just going to take a while in the grander scheme of things to make a comparison between the two.

Antonelli, the sky is the limit. But for Verstappen, the sky is still the limit because he's still got, if he wants it, so many years in him and he's so good. And it's fantastic to have two drivers of that caliber, plus a remarkable batch of other drivers actually to enjoy watching.

3:28

Josh Suttill

Yeah, I mean Verstappen has been blindingly quick from the start, isn't he? Just kind of like Antonelli has by year two. And you can kind of say, oh, well, what was Verstappen doing in his second year? Obviously, he got promoted and made to the main team, won his first race there, was having a good year. If you compare his 2016 to Antonelli's 2026, you know, you would say Antonelli's had the more impressive year, but equally, you know, have Verstappen say gone straight into the Red Bull in 15 and then was in a championship challenging car in 16

I feel like he'd have still got the job done. And also, their careers before F1 were very different, weren't they? I mean, they were both fast-tracked, but Verstappen was incredibly fast-tracked. You know, Antonelli did have a bit more preparation. And crucially, the work that Mercedes did to get him, you know, a ton of mileage in old F1 machinery, I think was really crucial to having this foundation to fast-track a bit of that lack of experience. So overall, you know, Antonelli's second year, I think he is ahead of where Verstappen was in their second year in F1. But with the caveat that that's probably because Antonelli had a bit more kind of coming into F1.

Read the other 43 minutes of this episode here.

$15 gets you this episode and 99 more. Credits never expire. After checkout, one link brings you back here to read it.

Not what you expected? Full refund within 14 days.

Thousands of transcripts fetched by people building searchable podcast archives

Fetch transcripts with code

The same credits work from a script or an AI agent. The demo key returns a sample episode in full, no card needed:

request
curl -H "x-api-key: pt_demo" \
  https://spoken.md/transcripts/1000651996090

Markdown with the speakers named, for your notes, your knowledge base, or anything that makes HTTP calls.

From $0.10 per transcript. No subscription. Credits never expire. Prices exclude VAT, added at checkout for EU customers. Not what you expected? Email us within 14 days with 20 or fewer credits used and we refund the pack in full.

Using your own key:

request
curl -H "x-api-key: YOUR_KEY" \
  https://spoken.md/transcripts/1000798396674