Daily Crypto Deep Dive: Meme Coins — Smart Investment or Pure Gambling? When Should You Sell? artwork

Daily Crypto Deep Dive: Meme Coins — Smart Investment or Pure Gambling? When Should You Sell?

Crypto News Today

October 21, 2026

🛡️ Protect yourself online with NordVPN: Get NordVPN here 🎧 Follow Crypto News Today on Spotify: Listen and follow MEME COINS: THE GREATEST INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITY OR THE BIGGEST GAMBLING TRAP IN CRYPTO?

0:00

SPEAKER_1

Welcome back to the Daily Crypto Deep Dive. Imagine putting $1,000 into a meme coin. A few weeks later, that $1,000 has become $10,000.

Your phone is going mad. Everybody on X is predicting another tenfold increase. Influencers are telling you that selling now would be the biggest mistake of your life. So you hold. The price doubles again, and your investment reaches $20,000.

You start thinking about what you could do with the money. But then the market turns. It drops 30%, then 50%, then 80%.

Six months later, you're looking at a portfolio worth less than you originally invested. You were right about the coin, right about the opportunity, and still managed to lose money. So here's the question we're tackling today on Crypto News Today. Are meme coins legitimate long-term investments? Or are they simply gambling instruments where the only sensible strategy is to buy early, take your profits and get off the train before everybody else realizes it's heading for a crash? And there's a second question that I think is even more interesting. If meme coins are fundamentally ridiculous, why have some extraordinarily intelligent and financially successful people bought them? We're talking about the co-founder of Ethereum, billionaire investors, professional crypto analysts, and even institutional investment researchers. Today we're examining the actual numbers, the psychology of these markets, the people who have made millions, and whether holding a meme coin for 10 years is financial conviction or simply refusing to admit that the party has finished.

Let's begin with the size of this market, because the numbers are astonishing. According to CoinGecko's state of meme coins research, the entire meme coin sector reached a peak valuation of approximately $150.6 billion in December 2024 That's an extraordinary amount of speculative value tied up in cryptocurrencies largely associated with dogs, frogs, internet jokes, and online communities. Fast forward to October 21st, 2026, and the sector is worth roughly $30 billion.

That's approximately an 80% collapse from its peak. Now that doesn't mean $120 billion in actual cash was withdrawn from these markets, because market capitalization is not the same thing as money invested. But it demonstrates how dramatically the collective valuation of an entire asset class can disappear when enthusiasm changes. Look at the individual examples. Dogecoin reached approximately 73 cents in May 2021, and now trades around 8 cents, nearly 89% below its record. Shiba Inu is approximately 94% below its highest price. Pepe, despite its extraordinary popularity, is roughly 84% below its peak. Dogwifhat, which once traded close to $4.83, is now around 21 cents, a decline of more than 95%, and Pudgy Penguins, which we'll discuss in greater detail shortly, trades around $0.008, compared with its historical high of approximately $0.06845.

That's a fall approaching 88%.

Every one of those projects has supporters who genuinely believe the best days are still ahead. But the fundamental question is whether the previous highs represent future opportunities or simply the prices that excited buyers were once willing to pay. And here's something fascinating about the data. CoinGecko's research into different cryptocurrency narratives showed that its selected basket of major meme coins recorded an average price gain of approximately 2,185% during 2024 That's enough to convince almost anyone that meme coins are the greatest investment opportunity on the planet.

Yet in 2025, the equivalent meme coin narrative basket recorded an average loss of approximately 31.6%.

Those baskets were selected retrospectively and aren't evidence of what the average trader earned but they demonstrate how violently performance can change. The same asset class that produces extraordinary wealth during a speculative frenzy can become a relentless destroyer of capital when the cycle reverses.

Finance researcher David Krause, an emeritus assistant professor at Marquette University, published a study in February 2026 examining an equally weighted portfolio of 10 major meme coins between January 2025 and February 2026 His findings were particularly uncomfortable for anyone advocating long-term passive holding. The hypothetical portfolio lost approximately 78.7%, compared with a loss of around 30.7% for Bitcoin over the same period. The S and P 500 gained approximately 17.8%, while gold advanced approximately 92.5%.

Krause also found annualized volatility of more than 100%.

It's important to stress that this was a pre-print rather than an independently peer-reviewed final paper, and one period cannot settle the debate forever. But the results are a powerful challenge to the idea that simply buying a selection of popular meme coins and waiting is a reliable route to wealth. Now this is where we need to introduce somebody who fundamentally disagrees with the idea that all meme coins should be treated as disposable lottery tickets. His name is Murad Mahmudov, and he's one of the most prominent advocates of the so-called meme coin supercycle. Speaking in 2024, Murad made an important distinction between two completely different types of meme coin activity. The first was the rapid buying and selling of newly launched tokens, which he described as hyper gambling. The second was the development of communities that could eventually become enormous cultural movements, potentially creating something capable of lasting like Dogecoin. In his argument, a successful meme coin isn't necessarily valued because of technology, revenue or cash flow. It's valued because people believe in the community, identify with the brand and want to be part of something bigger than themselves. There's something interesting about that argument. Think about fashion brands, collectibles, football clubs or luxury watches. Their market value is often influenced by identity, scarcity, emotional attachment and social status. Not everything valuable produces a dividend. A painting doesn't pay interest, and a rare collectible doesn't generate cash flow, yet people are prepared to pay enormous sums for both. Murad's argument is effectively that internet communities can become valuable social assets in their own right. His critics would argue that this is simply a sophisticated explanation for speculative behavior. But I don't think we can dismiss the cultural component entirely, particularly when Dogecoin has survived multiple cryptocurrency cycles since 2013

Read the other 10 minutes of this episode here.

$15 gets you this episode and 99 more. Credits never expire. After checkout, one link brings you back here to read it.

Not what you expected? Full refund within 14 days.

Thousands of transcripts fetched by people building searchable podcast archives

Fetch transcripts with code

The same credits work from a script or an AI agent. The demo key returns a sample episode in full, no card needed:

request
curl -H "x-api-key: pt_demo" \
  https://spoken.md/transcripts/1000651996090

Markdown with the speakers named, for your notes, your knowledge base, or anything that makes HTTP calls.

From $0.10 per transcript. No subscription. Credits never expire. Prices exclude VAT, added at checkout for EU customers. Not what you expected? Email us within 14 days with 20 or fewer credits used and we refund the pack in full.

Using your own key:

request
curl -H "x-api-key: YOUR_KEY" \
  https://spoken.md/transcripts/1000797517593