Why Did Brendan Banfield’s Own Lawyer Walk Away After Sentencing?

**SPEAKER_1** (0:00)
This is Hidden Killers With Tony Brueski. Here now, Tony Brueski.

**Tony Brueski** (0:07)
Brendan Banfield. It's been a little while since we talked about him, but the sentencing has finally taken place. Brendan Banfield, stood in a Fairfax County courtroom and listened to a judge call him evil. Not reckless, not troubled. A man who made a terrible mistake, evil. Judge Penney Azcarate told him, the level of cruelty, calculation and inhumanity in his case reflected something far deeper than anger or impulse. She carried no burden and found no hesitation in sending him away for the rest of his life. And then she made sure he understood something else. Five years ago, the crime he was convicted of would have carried a death sentence. Virginia abolished capital punishment in 2021 Lucky for Brendan, aggravated murder became the state's most serious charge, mandatory life without parole. Brandon Banfield got the maximum that the law allows. The judge wanted him to sit with the fact that if the calendar had been different, the conversation they were having would have been about something far worse than a prison cell.
That's not necessarily standard sentencing language. Judges don't typically remind defendants what their sentences would have been under a prior version of the law. But this judge wasn't being academic. She was making sure a man who spent three years manipulating everyone around him, his wife, his op-air, law enforcement and eventually a jury, understood the full weight of what he had done and she did it without raising her voice.
If you've been following this case, you know the story. If you haven't, here's a quick little catch you up, if you will. I'd love to get your thoughts in the comment section on Substack and YouTube. On the sentencing, how the judge handled it, all of it. Be sure to weigh in there. The links are in the description. Brendan Banfield was a former IRS law enforcement officer living in Herndon, Virginia, with his wife Christine, their young daughter, and the family's live-in au pair, Juliana Peres Magalhães. Magalhães came from Brazil. She was hired to help care for the couple's daughter, who was four years old at the time. Everything fell apart. Brandon started an affair with Magalhães in August of 22 Within a couple of months, according to Magalhães' testimony and court filings, he told her he wanted to get rid of Christine, but he didn't want to divorce.
Christine would have gotten more money. He'd have lost custody of his daughter. So he came up with something else. You know, there's something else. It usually is the beginning of many Dateline episodes. Banfield created fake online profiles impersonating his wife on dating websites. He used those profiles to catfish a man named Joseph Ryan, a complete stranger who had no idea what he was walking into. Ryan was lured into the Banfield home on the morning of February 24th, 2023 Under completely pretenses, he believed he was arriving for a consensual encounter that Christine had arranged. Instead, Banfield shot him with his government-issued firearm. And then he stabbed Christine seven times in the neck. Their four-year-old daughter was in the basement of the house, waiting to go to the zoo while it happened.
The 911 call framed Ryan as an intruder who had attacked Christine Banfield in Magalhães told responding officers they'd come home to find a stranger in the house. For months, it looked like it might work. It didn't. In October 23, police arrested Magalhães. During interviews, she broke. She admitted to her role in the killings, provided a detailed account of the plot, and eventually agreed to cooperate with prosecutors. She pled guilty to manslaughter and testified against Banfield at trial, and her testimony did what three years of investigation alone hadn't. It put a narrator inside the plot. She walked the jury through every step, the affair, the planning, the fake profiles, the way Banfield rehearsed how the night would go, the staging of the crime scene afterwards, and according to Magalhães, Banfield told her he wanted to marry her and have children with her, but Christine had to go first. A divorce meant losing money, and custody, murder meant keeping both. She described him creating the profiles, communicating with Ryan for weeks, engineering every detail of what was supposed to look like that home invasion. Banfield made the decision to take the stand in his own defense, because he's kind of an idiot. That's a rare move in a murder trial, and it's almost always a gamble. He acknowledged the affair with Magalhães, but denied any plot to kill Christine. His version? He left the house that morning for a work meeting. Magalhães called to tell him there was a stranger in the home. He rushed back, grabbed his firearm, went upstairs and found Ryan with his wife. Christine called out that Ryan had a knife, and according to Banfield, he fired to protect her.