Mac Defends Benching Anthony Volpe and Critiques Brian Cashman artwork

Mac Defends Benching Anthony Volpe and Critiques Brian Cashman

The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

July 9, 2026

Mac revisits a nostalgic 2008 radio segment featuring Johan Santana's shutout performance before engaging in a heated debate with callers about the Yankees. He argues that Anthony Volpe should be benched in favor of Jose Caballero due to prolonged offensive struggles.
Speakers: Craig Carton, Chris McMonigle, Bob
**Craig Carton** (0:00)
All right, 625 Now, is this her, is this Bonnie Tyler as well?

**Chris McMonigle** (0:08)
This is Bonnie Tyler.

**Craig Carton** (0:09)
She's Total Eclipse of the Heart is another one of hers, right?

**Chris McMonigle** (0:12)
This is it.

**Craig Carton** (0:13)
This is Total Eclipse of the Heart, right?

**Chris McMonigle** (0:14)
I screwed up the timing of it, yeah.

**SPEAKER_4** (0:16)
It's also a live version or something, it's throwing me off.

**Chris McMonigle** (0:19)
It's a different version. It's official.

**Craig Carton** (0:21)
Yeah, I don't know what this is. All right, we're going to move on from it, because you also gave me different news. You gave me news you found the piece I did for Summers.

**SPEAKER_4** (0:27)
Now I don't know how good it was, again. It just stands out in my mind, because I remember being asked to do it. I remember how annoyed he was the next day.
I remember the idea that it led into the disaster that was the end of Shea. But let's hear if this is any good. But this is a piece I did, Pete found it, a piece I did for Summers with the song from Bonnie Taylor, I Need a Hero.

**Chris McMonigle** (0:51)
2008 So we're going back to what?

**Craig Carton** (0:54)
September 2008 Yeah, we're going back a long time ago.

**SPEAKER_4** (0:59)
The Yankees have won a World Series more recently than this piece. None of us had been to Citi Field or the New Yankee Stadium.

**Craig Carton** (1:08)
That's how long it is. That's how long I've been here.

**SPEAKER_4** (1:10)
So it goes all the way back to September of 2008, when I was running the board for Steve Summers. Here's the piece I did on Johan Santana's big time performance, game 161, 2008

**SPEAKER_5** (1:28)
This was his choice.
He came in and begged for tomorrow's game, regardless. He said, I'm pitching him off.

**SPEAKER_2** (1:53)
Santana once again checks third, the 2-2 pitch, and it's lined in the air to right. Ryan Church is there, moves up, makes the catch, and that retires the side. Santana makes the big pitch to Baker in the Marlins, leaving him loaded in the fifth.

**SPEAKER_6** (2:14)
1-2 pitch is swung on and missed. A change up gets Uglah, the sixth strike out of the game for Santana, and it is 2-0 match behind their ace.

**SPEAKER_2** (2:40)
Here's the one-two pitch. And it's in there! A call strike three! Stuck him up with a fastball. Santana pumps his fist into the pocket of his glove. As he walks off the mound, 104 pitches in his pocket, Having shut out the Marlins on two hits through eight innings. I would have to think he's gonna start the night.
Accepts the one-two pitch, ripped in the air, left field, deep but playable. Chavez on the warning track, put it in the books. A brilliant performance by Johann Santana, who shuts out the Florida Marlins on three hits, and has given the Mets a win and some life.

**Bob** (3:40)
That's how you say it, I guess.

**Craig Carton** (3:43)
Oh, that takes you back.

**SPEAKER_4** (3:46)
That takes you back. That's like it. He comes in at 425 Can I have something for Santana earlier today?
I'm like, yeah, I'll figure something out. Paul must not have been here that time.

**Chris McMonigle** (4:00)
Right, and I bet the best part is about Steve, and I love it, and I'm going to go behind the fourth wall here, is when if you're like, I'll try, I'll see what I could do, especially when you're new, he's like, well, you know, Monzo could have done it. McMonigle would do it.

**SPEAKER_4** (4:14)
I know your heart's in the right place. That used to get that old time.
I know your heart's in the right place.

**Chris McMonigle** (4:23)
Impressive.

**SPEAKER_4** (4:23)
No, I know you're a good guy. Your heart's in the right place, I know.

**Chris McMonigle** (4:27)
You're going to be the station, I can feel.

**Craig Carton** (4:29)
Oh, yeah. Who knew he was right?

**Chris McMonigle** (4:31)
Yeah.

**SPEAKER_4** (4:33)
A little braggadocious there. But yes, that goes back to September of 2008 when I did that real quick piece for Steve.
Oh, boy, those are the days. Back in Studio C, I was editing that one. I remember it. I don't know why.

**Craig Carton** (4:47)
888-808-109.

**SPEAKER_4** (4:48)
So a little nostalgia there for you Met fans.

**Craig Carton** (4:51)
And you say I never talk Met's. Piece of history right there. A piece of history.

**SPEAKER_4** (4:55)
A piece of Met history right there.

**Craig Carton** (4:59)
The next day didn't go as well.

14 more minutes of transcript below

Feed this to your agent

Try it now — copy, paste, done:

curl -H "x-api-key: pt_demo" \
  https://spoken.md/transcripts/1000651996090

Works with Claude, ChatGPT, Cursor, and any agent that makes HTTP calls.

From $0.10 per transcript. No subscription. Credits never expire.

Using your own key:

curl -H "x-api-key: YOUR_KEY" \
  https://spoken.md/transcripts/1000776187158